Profile
name: Syed Asadullah
Menu
Prophet’s picture in textbook stirs row in Uttar Pradesh, India Compiled by Syed Asadullah
29 July, 2009
Islam and Pluralism Wednesday, 29 Jul 2009
‘Love in Jihad’ – Myth or Reality?

Are Muslim boys luring Hindu girls to love and marriage in order to convert them to Islam deliberately, on purpose, as part of a Jihad, as communal and divisive elements in India are propagating? Prominent Delhi-based Urdu columnist Maulana Nadeemul Wajidee looks at the issue, in the process revealing his own mindset and outlook, indeed a worldview widely prevalent in our Mullah class – no introspection, merely blaming others, contempt for religions brought to the world by prophets preceding Prophet Mohammad - respecting whom equally as our own Prophet is an essential, inalienable part of our Faith. I am particularly offended by the fact that Maulana Saheb shows no regard for the sentiments of our ahl-e-kitab brethren in India: he seeks God’s protection from the Satan by saying Naooz billah before relating the fact that some Muslim boys and indeed girls too are converting to Hinduism for love.

Maulana Saheb also reveals total insensitivity to the emotion of love. For his class of maulanas, women are nothing more than child-bearing machines, or at best, an object of occasional lust. Indeed he says so in so many words in this article reproduced below (Translated by Syed Raihan Ahmad Nezami). How can he possibly understand that love is the highest virtue a human can aspire to? Love is Truth. Love is God. And love is universal. It is not for nothing that couples in love are prepared to sacrifice their all for love. And they do. Everywhere in the world and in all ages. Only today I read the story of teenager Afsana and a Dalit boy Manoj, brutally killed in a Meerut village allegedly by Afsana’s brothers, with the connivance of the entire village and support of probably the majority of our countrymen of all faiths.

Of course, no Muslim is falling in love or luring Hindu girls to love and marriage and conversion as part of a Jihad or any other conspiracy. The very idea is preposterous. But, those who don’t want to see India prosper would not let go of any opportunity to divide the country. The Maulana may be right in seeking to dispel the notion, even though the idea is too ludicrous to be given such serious notice.

However, the sooner our Maulanas learn to see Islam as just one of the many religions in the world brought to the world by tens of thousands of prophets or messengers of God in every part of the world, as the Holy Quran informs us, the better. According to Quranic teachings, we Muslims have no distinction over other religious communities. The only factor that could have given us distinction– taqwa (piety) – is present in us in more or less the same measure as in other communities. So why should we feel superior in the eyes of God than other religious communities? Islam-supremacism is not only untenable and unsustainable from the teachings of Islam itself; this is also the cause of many of our woes. Indeed feeling and even acting superior is proof that we are inferior beings in the eyes of God. No pious person can have contempt for other creations of God and even consider them lesser beings. Remeber Hoqooqul Ibad is more important in Islam than even Hoqooqullah.

Sultan Shahin, Editor, New Age Islam

1 Comments More...
 
Urdu Section
 
Islam and Sectarianism: The reality of Deobandi-Bareilvi clash
 

By Maulana Nademul Wajidi

 


More...
 
 
Islamic World News
 
No Burqa For Clinton
 

Prophet’s picture in textbook stirs row in Uttar Pradesh, India by IANS

Hafiz Saeed – India’s Most Wanted Free in Pakistan by Mukhtar A. Khan

Wheree did US Ten billion dollar aid to Pakistan go? by Dr Ashfaque H Khan

Nigerian Islamist Attacks Spread

Al Qaeda seen gaining new foothold in Yemen by Andrew Hammond

Nigeria and Al Qaeda by Douglas Farah

Sufi Soul: A List of Essential Sufi Books

Hamas dress code aims to make Gaza more Islamic by DIAA HADID

Global media’s war by Manzoor Ali Memon

Pakistan arts-lovers defy Taliban stage fright by David Loyn

Ironic similarity of Iranian women to Iranian Baha'i's by Faramarz_Fateh

German University Takes Step toward Integrating Islamic Education by Bernd Volkert

Compiled by Syed Asadullah


More...
 
 
Debate
 
Asad Farooqui responds to Sultan Shahin’s plea of forgiveness on Babri mosque dispute
 

Mr. Sultan Shahin has made an excellent suggestion to the Indian Muslims on the late Babri Masjid. While I support his suggestion of taking the spiritual path of forgiveness, I must express some reservations that I have.  Mr. Shahin is apparently a very highly spiritually evolved Muslim. But he doesn’t seem to have his feet firmly on the ground.

Sultan Shahin on Babri mosque dispute: A spiritual response

http://www.newageislam.org/NewAgeIslamArticleDetail.aspx?ArticleID=1559

 

Babri Masjid: Opportunity for Muslims 

by Sultan Shahin

http://www.newageislam.org/NewAgeIslamArticleDetail.aspx?ArticleID=1514

 

We adopted the practice of outsourcing of religion 14 centuries ago, something that all other religions used to follow before us and Islam had come to finish off. 

2 Comments More...
 
 
Current affairs
 
A Fascinating Shift in the Way India Relates To Pakistan
 

Sharm El-Sheikh Joint Declaration May Be Manmohan Singh’s Big Gamble on India-Pakistan Relations

It may be early days yet, but events of the past two weeks point towards a fascinating shift in the way India relates to Pakistan, by de-hyphenating its own policy towards the US and others engaged in Project Pakistan. Manmohan Singh’s government has now announced India’s intention to break away from a Pakistan-centric view of its Pakistan policy and join this larger project, thereby globalising its Pakistan strategy. The US and India, therefore, for the first time in their engagement, are talking less of Pakistan’s compliance on one incident or the other, but on its very future. There are risks, particularly in a situation where your friends (the US) could be as unpredictable as your adversaries. But Manmohan Singh has decided to lead his troops out of the trenches, says Shekhar Gupta, editor-in-chief of the Indian Express, New Delhi, one of the most insightful observers of Indian foreign policy among Indian opinion makers.


More...
 
 
Islamic Sharia Laws
 
Putting India’s Muslim Personal Law in Perspective
 

Muslim Personal Law is not tantamount to shari’a

Secondly, as the great Indian jurist A. A. A. Fyzee explained in 1963, MPL is not tantamount to shari’a because so many dimensions of law from the colonial period on, including criminal law and the all-important law of precedent and procedure, are secularly defined. In a headline-grabbing alleged rape by her father-in-law of a poor Muslim country woman named Imrana two years back, there was considerable discussion of MPL, even an ill-informed denunciation of it in The New York Times by the acclaimed writer Salman Rushdie, though MPL was in no way at all involved. What was at stake was a fatwa (advising the woman to sever her current marriage), which was completely ignored. --   Barbara Metcalf, Professor of History and Director of the Centre for South Asian Studies at the University of Michigan.


More...
 
 
Spiritual Meditations
 
Muslims at prayer - 2
 

More...
 
 
Radical Islamism & Jihad
 
Whither Pakistan? A Five Year Forecast
 

Religious extremism is devouring Pakistan

The clouds hanging over the future of Pakistan's state and society are getting darker. Collapse isn't impending, but there is a slow-burning fuse. While timescales cannot be mathematically forecast, the speed of societal decline has surprised many who have long warned that religious extremism is devouring Pakistan.Here is how it all went down the hill: The 2001 U.S. invasion of Afghanistan devastated the Taliban. Many fighters were products of madrasas in Pakistan, and their trauma was partly shared by their erstwhile benefactors in the Pakistan military and intelligence. Recognizing that this force would remain important for maintaining Pakistani influence in Afghanistan--and keep the low-intensity war in Kashmir going--the army secretly welcomed them on Pakistani soil. Rebuilding and rearming was quick, especially as the United States tripped upin Afghanistan after a successful initial victory. -- Pervez Hoodbhoy


More...
 
 
Books and Documents
 
The Function of Deen: From “Islam A Challenge to Religion” by Allama Ghulam Ahmad Parwez
 

Obviously, Islam fulfils all the requirements of Deen. Islam, as Iqbal puts it, "is neither dogma, nor priesthood, nor ritual."8 It is much more than any of these or all of these. It is the vivid sense of God's directive force and unflinching working of His laws. It is absolute iman in God's wisdom and His purpose. It is hearty participation in the upward progressive trend and movement of life and the world viewed as the expression of God's creative force. Islam stands for life-fulfilment and rejects life-denial as unworthy of man. It commands us to face facts and not to shrink from them and take refuge in fantasy, and requires us to control and harness natural forces for achieving our ends. Asceticism, quietism and monasticism are all repugnant to Islam. Islam lays stress oil social life and on its value for man, and does not regard the body as an evil and as an impediment to "spiritual" progress. It wants man to respect the rights of the body as well as the rights of the self. For this reason, Islam does not approve of self-abnegation and self-mortification. There is nothing mysterious in it and it has no place for mysticism. It aims at the establishment of a social order based on permanent values in which all its members act as free agents striving for a higher and noble cause of making man’s abode on this earth more beautiful, and making him fit for further evolutionary stages of life.

    Islam, as a living force, will continue to play a vital role in the moral uplift and social, cultural and political unification of mankind. It will continue to make valuable contributions to the knowledge and culture of mankind. Above all, it will continue to enrich the "spiritual" 9 life of man and thus strengthen and elevate his self or his personality. -- Allama Ghulam Ahmad Parwez

1 Comments More...
 
 
Islamic Society
 
Muslims at Prayer -- 1
 

1 Comments More...
 
 
War on Terror
 
America, Give Pakistanis Books, not Guns
 

Unfortunately, the United States has acted in ways that have often empowered the militants. We have lavished more than $11 billion on Pakistan since 9/11, mostly supporting the Pakistani Army. Yet that sum has bought Pakistan no security and us no good will. In that same poll, 59 percent of Pakistanis said that they share many of Al Qaeda’s attitudes toward the United States, and almost half of those said that they support Al Qaeda attacks on Americans. One reason is that America hasn’t stood up for its own values in Pakistan. Instead of supporting democracy, we cold-shouldered the lawyers’ movement, which was the best hope for democracy and civil society. -- NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF

2 Comments More...
 
 
Islam and the West
 
Israel steals Palestinian’s history too: 1948 no catastrophe, say Arab text books in Israel now
 

Israel's education ministry has ordered the removal of the word nakba – Arabic for the "catastrophe" of the 1948 war – from a school textbook for young Arab children, it has been announced. The decision – which will alter books aimed at eight- and nine-year-old Arab pupils – will be seen as a blunt assertion by Binyamin Netanyahu's Likud-led government of Israel's historical narrative over the Palestinian one. -- Ian Black, Middle East editor, Guardian, London


More...
 
 
Ijtihad, Rethinking Islam
 
Rethinking Islam: Need for ijtihad is paramount
 

Serious rethinking within Islam is long overdue. Muslims have been comfortably relying, or rather falling back, on age-old interpretations for much too long.

This is why we feel so painful in the contemporary world, so uncomfortable with modernity. Scholars and thinkers have been suggesting for well over a century that we need to make a serious attempt at Ijtihad, at reasoned struggle and rethinking, to reform Islam. At the beginning of the last century, Jamaluddin Afghani and Mohammad Abduh led the call for a new Ijtihad; and along the way many notable intellectuals, academics and sages have added to this plea - not least Mohammad Iqbal, Malik bin Nabbi and Abdul Qadir Audah. Yet, ijtihad is one thing Muslim societies have singularly failed to undertake. Why? -- Ziauddin Sardar

6 Comments More...
 
 
Urdu Section
 
Pakistan: No one can change our condition until we decide to change it ourselves
 

By: Irshad Ahmad Haqqani

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1 Comments More...
 
 
Islam and Science
 
Indian Maulanas using solar eclipse for spreading superstition
 

Maulana Nadeemul Wajidi takes the lead

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

9 Comments More...
 
 
Islam and Politics
 
A tragic joke plays out in proud Iran
 

Allow me to quote the British novelist Martin Amis, writing about Persia in the Guardian: “Iran is one of the most venerable civilisations on earth: it makes China look like an adolescent, and America look like a stripling”. Iranians, aware of that history, are a proud people. They do not take kindly to being played around with, nor to seeing their country turned into a laughing stock. They do not like the memory of an election campaign that now seems like pure theatre, the expression of the sadistic whim of some puppeteer. So the line I take away from the important Friday sermon of Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani, the two-time former President who believes that the Islamic Republic’s future lies in compromise rather than endless confrontation, is this one: “We shouldn’t let our enemies laugh at us because we’ve imprisoned our own people”. There’s been tragedy aplenty since June 12 — dozens of killings, thousands of arrests, countless beatings of the innocent — and I hope I belittle none of it when I say there’s also been something laughable. -- Roger Cohen

Photo:  Hojjatoleslam Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani

3 Comments More..
Egyptian Cleric explains Wife-Beating in Islam
08 February, 2009
Islamic World News
 
Egyptian Cleric explains Wife-Beating in Islam
 

2. Indonesians ignore religious edicts against smoking, yoga

3. Shining a light on Islam's hidden scientific treasure

4. Most wanted Nazi converted to Islam, died in Egypt

5. World Muslim Scholars to Meet In Kuala Lumpur

6. Islam, democracy, human rights compatible – Shirin Ebadi

7. German, Tunisian sentenced in synagogue attack

8. Austria debates democratic credentials of its Islam teachers

9. CAIR Welcomes Obams's Islamic Reference

10. Iraq's Maliki emerges as forceful nationalist

11. Terror suspects maintain contact with terrorist groups

12. Editor Upholds Ideology of Iran's Islamic Revolution

13. Hamas are Sunnis! - Tariq Alhomayed

14. Anti-Islam UK teacher sues bosses for 100 K pounds

15. Fearful erosion of liberties -- Andrew Shaw

Compiled by Syed Asadullah


More..
Posted by syedmdasadullah 10:51 | Syed Asadullah | Comment(0) | Permalink
Jihadi attack on Mumabi - The Rationale of Terror
08 February, 2009
Radical Islamism & Jihad
 
Jihadi attack on Mumabi - The Rationale of Terror
 

The Rationale of Terror -- Patrick J. Buchanan

What Is the Message of Terrorism --William Pfaff

Terrorist Attacks Rock Mumbai, Stun the World -- M.M. Ali

Hindus, Jews and Jehadi terror  - Andrew J Boston

Terrorists All Around, yet We Slumber -- Herb Denenberg

Terror suspects in contact with terrorist groups - Alan Travis


More..
Posted by syedmdasadullah 10:50 | Syed Asadullah | Comment(2) | Permalink
The “Hidden Imam” of the Shiites – myth or reality?
08 February, 2009
Islam and Sectarianism
The “Hidden Imam” of the Shiites – myth or reality?

The existence of the Hidden Imam rests upon nothing other than acceptance of the words of those who claim to be his representatives. If this is not mythology what different name one can give it, According to their part of the story, the Hidden Imam even used to read, write, and edit books. This is an unbelievable story, that too coming from a sect claiming to be Muslim, whose beliefs stem from the recorded history of the existence of Prophet (PBUH) and the Book of Allah, the Holy Qur'an.  These events of history and records are certainly not a myth like the myth of hidden Imam. Mainstream Islam is renowned for its rationalism and proud of its sustained struggle against superstition of all sorts…. Issues of faith, in a rationalist religion like Islam at least, can never be based upon this kind of flimsy evidence. -- A.M. Jamsheed Basha

17 Comments More.
Posted by syedmdasadullah 10:50 | Syed Asadullah | Comment(0) | Permalink
An Indecent Attempt to Tarnish the Image of the Companions of the Prophet
08 February, 2009
Islamic History
 
An Indecent Attempt to Tarnish the Image of the Companions of the Prophet
 

Maulana Nadeem-ul-Wajidee critiques Arif Mohammad Khan’s “fallacious” arguments on Yazid’s succession and Karbala

 Maulana Nadeem-ul-Wajidee analyzes the "fallacious" arguments of former union minister Arif Mohammad Khan regarding the occurrence of Karbala, bringing the Sahaba-e-Karam (companions of the Prophet) into disrepute with reference to Yazid’s succession. He argues that a respect for all Sahaba-e-Karam is an essential part of Islamic faith. According to the Maulana the Sahaba could do no wrong and all their decisions have to be respected by all Muslims. He says that Mr. Arif Mohammad Khan’s arguments against the succession of Yazid are just a rehash of Maulana Maududi’s comments on the subject.

Transkated from Urdu by Syed Raihan Ahmad Nezami

12 Comments More...
Posted by syedmdasadullah 10:50 | Syed Asadullah | Comment(0) | Permalink
TURKEY: Goodbye to Long Friendship with Israel?
08 February, 2009
Islam and the West
 
TURKEY: Goodbye to Long Friendship with Israel?
 

Hilmi Toros: ISTANBUL, Feb 5 (IPS) - For decades, isolated Israel could count on Turkey as its only Muslim friend, if not ally, in the tumultuous Middle East. After Israel's assault on Gaza, that friendship is in doubt.

 M.K. Bhadrakumar: Turkey wades into Middle Eastern great game

 Turkey’s Middle East Policies: Between Neo-Ottomanism and Kemalism

Omer Taspinar, Carnegie Paper, September 2008:  “The stakes for Turkey and the future of the Middle East are high. Home to more than 70 million Muslims, Turkey is the most advanced democracy in the Islamic world. A stable, western-oriented, liberal Turkey on a clear path toward the EU would serve as a growing market for western goods, a contributor to the labour force Europe will desperately need in the coming decades, a democratic example for the rest of the Muslim world, a stabilizing influence on Iraq, and a partner in Afghanistan. An authoritarian, resentful, and isolated Turkey, on the other hand, would be the opposite in every case. If its domestic politics were to go wrong, Turkey would not only cease being a democratic success story but also could become a destabilizing factor in the Middle East.”


More..
Posted by syedmdasadullah 10:47 | Syed Asadullah | Comment(0) | Permalink
UK challenging Radical Islamism by promoting Mainstream Islam
08 February, 2009
Radical Islamism & Jihad
 
UK challenging Radical Islamism by promoting Mainstream Islam
 

UK’s four- pronged approach to de-radicalise its Muslim minority holds important lessons for the Indian effort to counter extremism at home.

Recently, I had the opportunity to study aspects of the first strand of the Four P’s strategy — preventing the emergence of violent radicalism on the part of the Muslim youth in the UK. The plan addresses disadvantage, mis-perception, and alienation by putting money into a number of projects addressing inequality and discrimination. Targeted schemes have sought to improve the educational and physical infrastructure of the ghettoes, and even more boldly, to directly challenge radical theology by promoting moderate Islam as well as inter-faith dialogue. The approach has been to knit together various ministries, local governments, civil society, community institutions like mosques, gurudwaras and temples to attack the problem. -- Manoj Joshi


More..
Posted by syedmdasadullah 10:47 | Syed Asadullah | Comment(0) | Permalink
Ideological Battle is the Key: Support Mainstream Islam
08 February, 2009
Radical Islamism & Jihad
 
Ideological Battle is the Key: Support Mainstream Islam
 

The international fight against terrorism will be a long, hard slog. After all, the problem and solution are linked: Terrorism not only threatens the free, secular world, but also springs from the rejection of democratic and secular values. Worse, terrorism is pursued as a sanctified tool of religion and a path to redemption. Thus, the struggle against transnational terror can be won only by inculcating a liberal, secular ethos in societies steeped in religious and political bigotry….Washington's proposal to triple non-military aid to Islamabad while keeping existing military aid flow intact, other than to tie it to concrete Pakistani cooperation on the Afghan front, will free Pakistan to continue its asymmetric war of terror against India. -- Brahma Chellaney

 

Kashmir not the issue, Pak-Afghan border is

The Kashmir conflict is a very small part of this larger dynamic and with two consecutive successful elections, the last one witnessing around 60 per cent participation by Jammu and Kashmir’s electorate, it is hardly the reason why Mumbai was attacked or why the West is losing the war in Afghanistan. To rationalise the terrorist attacks in Mumbai by linking them to the Kashmir issue not only defies logic and is devoid of any serious analysis but it is also profoundly irresponsible and dangerous. It ignores Indian attempts over the past decade to acknowledge the aspirations of Kashmiris with the liberal, democratic and secular framework of its Constitution as well as bilateral attempts by India and Pakistan to reach some sort of understanding on this vexed issue. -- Harsh V. Pant

1 Comments More.
Posted by syedmdasadullah 10:47 | Syed Asadullah | Comment(0) | Permalink
'Anti-terrorism policy review, dialogue key to West-Muslims ties’
08 February, 2009
Islam and the West
 
Radical vs. Mainstream Islam: some reflections
 

'Anti-terrorism policy review, dialogue key to West-Muslims ties’

ISLAMABAD: Most of the foreign envoys based in Islamabad on Tuesday urged a review of the war on terror policies, dialogue with extremists and better relations between the Muslim and the West.

Speaking at a conference - Islam and the West: Future Agenda of Change (Role of the Muslim World) - organised by the Council of Islamic Ideology (CII), the envoys also called on the world to change its perception towards Islam and replace ‘might is right’ principle with ‘right is might’. The conference was convened to consider recommendations for US President Barack Obama to improve the West-Muslim relations.

 

Also: “Moderate" Muslims versus American-Muslims by Supna Zaidi

Finding the Moderate Muslims by Ben Shapiro

Government, FBI, Media Years behind Understanding

Radical Islam by Herb Denenberg

2 Comments More..
Posted by syedmdasadullah 10:41 | Syed Asadullah | Comment(0) | Permalink
Demanding fairplay is fine, but Azamgarh Muslims need to introspect too
08 February, 2009
Radical Islamism & Jihad
 
Demanding fairplay is fine, but Azamgarh Muslims need to introspect too
 

Muslims from Azamgarh were merely exercising their democratic right to peacefully protest a perceived discrimination and voice their demands for justice and fair treatment.

There is a general feeling in the Muslim community, and not only in Azamgarh, that after every terrorist act the police pick up innocent Muslim youth at random and even if they let them go after interrogation, their lives are already destroyed. They lose their jobs, marriages break down, their Muslim relatives and friends too start avoiding them, not to speak of their Hindu friends or employers. This has already happened to several Muslim youths in different parts of the country. ….

It is easy to blame the police and the government. Not that they do not deserve that blame sometimes. But while we have to try and keep them on their toes, through peaceful protests, through political mobilisation, and so on, that is not going to solve our problems in the long run. Even the denunciations of terrorism, that some of our ulema are organising in city after city, while useful, are not going to solve our problems. We need to introspect deeply, if there is something that could be wrong with us, with our understanding of our scriptures, and if there is something we can ourselves do to ameliorate our conditions instead of merely hoping and waiting for others to pull our chestnuts out of fire.

Sultan Shahin, editor, New Age Islam

22 Comments More.
Posted by syedmdasadullah 10:41 | Syed Asadullah | Comment(0) | Permalink
A service provided by Al Bawaba